While the decision to separate is undeniably complex and deeply personal for adults, there's a critical perspective often overlooked: the children. In the whirlwind of selling or moving houses, legal proceedings, emotional turmoil, and logistical changes, a fundamental question frequently goes unasked: "Is this what you want?"
Children, regardless of their age, are rarely given a voice in the decision-making process of their parents' separation. They are, in essence, passengers on a journey they didn't choose, navigating a landscape that is irrevocably altered without their consent. This lack of agency, this feeling of being an observer rather than a participant in a life-altering event, can have profound and often unintended consequences, particularly for their long-term mental health.
Unintended Consequences of an Unasked Question
When children are not consulted, even in an age-appropriate way, about their parents' separation, several subtle yet significant impacts can emerge:
Loss of Control and Helplessness: Imagine your entire world shifting beneath your feet, and you have no say in it. For a child, a divorce or separation can feel exactly like this. This profound sense of helplessness can linger, manifesting as anxiety, a struggle with decision-making later in life, or even a tendency to avoid difficult situations because they feel powerless to influence outcomes.
Erosion of Trust: Children naturally trust their parents to protect them and make decisions in their best interest. When separation occurs without their input, especially if it feels sudden or unexplained, that fundamental trust can be shaken. They may begin to question the reliability of adults, leading to difficulties forming secure attachments in future relationships. "If my parents couldn't keep their promises to each other, or to our family unit, how can I trust anyone else?" is a silent question many children carry.
Internalised Guilt and Self-Blame: Children, particularly younger ones, are egocentric in their thinking. They often believe they are the centre of their world, and thus, if something bad happens, it must be their fault. Without clear communication and reassurance that the separation is not about them, children can internalise immense guilt, believing their behavior, grades, or even their very existence somehow contributed to their parents' unhappiness. This can lead to low self-esteem, self-criticism, and a pervasive sense of inadequacy.
Emotional Suppression and Isolation: If children perceive that their feelings about the parental separation are not valued or heard, they may learn to suppress them. They might fear burdening their already stressed parents, or they may simply not know how to articulate the complex emotions they are experiencing. This can lead to emotional withdrawal, difficulty expressing themselves, and a feeling of isolation, even within their own family.
Accelerated Maturity (or Regression): Some children respond by attempting to "grow up" too quickly, taking on parental roles or becoming overly responsible to compensate for the perceived void. Others may regress, exhibiting behaviours typical of younger children as a way to cope with overwhelming stress. Both are unintended consequences of a situation they didn't choose and weren't prepared for.
Difficulty with Conflict Resolution: Witnessing their parents' inability to resolve their differences peacefully, especially if the separation is acrimonious, can teach children unhealthy patterns of conflict resolution. They may learn to avoid conflict entirely, or conversely, to engage in aggressive or passive-aggressive behaviours, reflecting what they observed.
It's crucial to understand that the presence of high, unresolved parental conflict after the separation often exacerbates negative mental health outcomes. When children are continuously exposed to animosity, blame, or are put in the middle of their parents' disputes, the psychological toll is much greater.
Staying Together for the Kids
Given the profound impact divorce and parental separation can have on children, it's natural for parents to consider staying together, even in an unhappy marriage, "for the kids' sake." This is a deeply ingrained societal notion, driven by a powerful desire to protect children from pain. However, staying in a high-conflict or dysfunctional relationship can often be more detrimental to a child's well-being than a carefully managed separation.
Children are incredibly perceptive. They absorb the emotional atmosphere of their home like sponges. When parents are constantly in conflict, emotionally distant, or engage in passive-aggressive behaviours, children witness and internalise this dynamic. Living in a home filled with tension, arguments, or an overwhelming sense of sadness can lead to:
● Chronic Stress and Anxiety: The constant exposure to parental discord can create a persistent state of fight-or-flight in children, leading to chronic stress, anxiety, and even physical health problems.
● Poor Emotional Modelling: Children learn how to navigate relationships and express emotions by observing their parents. If they only witness unhealthy conflict resolution, emotional suppression, or a lack of affection, they are likely to adopt these patterns themselves.
● Distorted Views of Relationships: An unhappy "intact" family can teach children that relationships and marriage are about enduring misery, conflict, or emotional emptiness, rather than a partnership built on respect and love. This can set them up for similar struggles in their own adult relationships.
● Internalised Family Dysfunction: Children may feel responsible for their parents' unhappiness or believe they need to "fix" the family, leading to immense pressure and guilt.
Ultimately, it is the quality of the family environment and the nature of the parental relationship, rather than the marital status itself, that has the most significant impact on children's mental health. A separation where parents manage conflict constructively, prioritise their children's needs, and co-parent respectfully can often lead to better outcomes for children than an intact marriage or relationship defined by chronic tension and unhappiness.
Giving Children a Voice (Even After the Fact)
While the decision to separate rests with the parents, acknowledging and validating a child's experience is paramount. It's never too late to open lines of communication and actively work to mitigate the potential for negative mental health outcomes.
● Listen Actively: Create safe spaces for children to express their feelings, fears, and frustrations without judgment. Validate their emotions, even if they're difficult to hear. Ask open-ended questions like, "What's been on your mind about all the changes?"
● Reassure and Reiterate: Consistently remind them that the divorce is not their fault. Emphasise that both parents still love them, even if they can no longer be together. This reassurance needs to be repeated often.
● Maintain Routines and Predictability: Children thrive on structure. Where possible, maintain familiar routines (school, extracurriculars, bedtime) and provide clear, consistent information about upcoming changes to help them feel more secure.
● Avoid Parental Conflict in Front of Children: This is perhaps one of the most critical factors for a child's well-being post-separation. Strive for respectful, business-like communication with your co-parent, keeping children out of the middle of any disagreements.
● Seek Professional Support: A child psychologist or therapist can provide a neutral, confidential space for children to process their emotions, develop healthy coping strategies, and understand that their feelings are normal and valid. They can also equip parents with tools for effective co-parenting.
Parental separation or divorce is a painful reality for many families. By recognising the profound impact it has on children, particularly their mental health, and by actively striving to give them a voice and support their emotional well-being, we can mitigate some of the unintended consequences and help them navigate this challenging transition with greater resilience and hope for their future. Their silent experiences deserve to be heard, acknowledged, and healed.
————————————————————————————
Our highly trained psychologists can help. Please call our team on 9882-8874 to book in with one of our team members today. Alternatively fill in our contact form here to get in touch.
To subscribe and listen to our podcast “Breaking the Rules: A Clinician’s Guide to Treating OCD”, click on the following links: Spotify, Google Podcasts, and Apple Podcasts. Episodes will be released fortnightly and will simultaneously be published on our webpage here.
This blog was written and prepared by Dr Celin Gelgec – Clinic Director and Clinical Psychologist at Melbourne Wellbeing Group.