When we think about decision making, it’s tempting to picture a careful, logical process: weighing up the pros and cons, analysing the risks, and calmly choosing the best option. Many of us pride ourselves on being “rational” and try to push emotions out of the equation.
But psychology and neuroscience tell us something quite different: emotions are not barriers to good decisions, they are essential to them. Without emotions, we would struggle to make even the simplest choices.
Why Logic Alone Isn’t Enough
Imagine being asked to choose what to eat for lunch. Now, imagine that every option feels equally neutral. The pasta looks fine. The sandwich looks fine. The salad looks fine. You can compare nutrients, calories, and prices all you like, but without any emotional preference, every option feels flat.
This is not a thought experiment. Researchers studying people with brain injuries that damaged emotional processing found exactly this: when emotions were blunted or absent, people couldn’t decide. Even simple, everyday choices became exhausting.
What this shows us is that logic provides the framework for decision making, but emotions provide the spark that allows us to move forward. They give meaning, weight, and urgency to our choices.
Decision Paralysis: When the Head Drowns Out the Heart
Most of us have experienced decision paralysis, that stuck, heavy feeling when the options pile up and no choice feels possible. It happens in small ways, like standing in a supermarket aisle unable to choose between twenty brands of cereal, and in bigger ways, like hesitating for months over a job change or relationship decision.
Often, decision paralysis happens when we try to lean too heavily on logic. We create lists of pros and cons, run mental simulations, and replay every possible scenario in our minds. We get caught in the idea that if we just think hard enough, we’ll find the “right” answer, the one that guarantees certainty and eliminates risk.
But certainty is a myth. No amount of thinking can completely protect us from regret, disappointment, or change. The harder we try to think our way to a perfect solution, the more overwhelmed we become.
What often breaks the paralysis is emotion. Maybe it’s the sense of relief you feel when you picture turning down the job offer, or the quiet excitement that bubbles up when you imagine saying yes. These emotions don’t give you a perfect answer, but they highlight what matters to you. They cut through the noise and help you move forward.
How Emotions Shape Our Choices
Emotions act like signals. They can draw our attention to risks, values, and opportunities that logic alone can miss.
Fear alerts us to potential danger and makes us cautious. Without fear, we might take reckless risks. With too much fear, we might avoid growth.
Joy and excitement energise us to pursue new opportunities. But unchecked, they can lead to impulsive leaps.
Guilt pulls us toward moral responsibility and care for others. At times, it can also trap us in over responsibility.
Sadness encourages reflection and helps us process loss, but it can also narrow our outlook and make the future feel hopeless.
Every emotion has both wisdom and distortion within it. The skill is in noticing the emotion and asking: What is this feeling telling me? and Is it a helpful guide here, or is it clouded by something else?
Finding Balance: Head and Heart Together
It’s not about letting emotions rule every decision. That can lead to impulsivity and short-term relief that creates long-term problems. But it’s also not about shutting emotions out. The most effective decisions come from integration — allowing both head and heart to have a voice.
Logic can help you plan, structure, and weigh consequences. Emotions can show you what truly matters and motivate you to act. Together, they create decisions that are both practical and meaningful.
Moving Through Paralysis
If you find yourself paralysed by decisions, here are some gentle reflections to try:
Notice what emotions come up when you imagine each choice. Relief? Dread? Excitement? Resentment?
Ask yourself: if logic couldn’t give me a perfect answer, what would my feelings suggest about what matters most?
Reflect on whether fear is protecting you from harm or keeping you stuck in comfort.
Remember that no decision eliminates uncertainty and that’s okay.
Sometimes, just acknowledging the emotions at play can be enough to break the stalemate.
Emotions are not the enemy of clear thinking; they are its foundation. They give colour and weight to our decisions, helping us navigate a world where certainty rarely exists. When we try to silence them, we often get stuck in endless analysis. When we listen to them thoughtfully, they point us toward what is meaningful.
The role of emotions in decision making is not to take over, but to remind us that choices are not just about outcomes, they’re about who we are and what we value.
————————————————————————————
Our highly trained psychologists can help. Please call our team on 9882-8874 to book in with one of our team members today. Alternatively fill in our contact form here to get in touch.
To subscribe and listen to our podcast “Breaking the Rules: A Clinician’s Guide to Treating OCD”, click on the following links: Spotify, Google Podcasts, and Apple Podcasts. Episodes will be released fortnightly and will simultaneously be published on our webpage here.